Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • Nov. 9, 1861
  • Page 11
  • CORRESPONDENCE.
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Nov. 9, 1861: Page 11

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Nov. 9, 1861
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article NOTES ON LITERATURE SCIENCE AND ART. ← Page 3 of 3
    Article CORRESPONDENCE. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 11

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Notes On Literature Science And Art.

tenth century the wages for lifting this stone Avas only one penny per man per diem . The Pinnacle and Eildon quarries now supply the neighbourhood . " The death of Mrs . Pye , relict of the late Henry Pye , reminds the world of a former poet-laureate , who ivas so little of a poet that his very name is almost forgotten . The Westminster Revieio thus hits the selfishness Avhich is

currently taught in the present day : — " If there is one thing more certain than another , it is , that the large majority of mankind must always live by the labour of their hands . In the eyes , therefore , of the political philosopher , AA-hatever concerns labour is of paramoufc importance . To give the labouring class such habits and such opportunities as may tend to raise it as a Avhole , is the object he has most at heart . Increased production , extended commerce , political liberty , the progress of science , he

regards ivifch indifference if they have not this tendency . For Avithout pretending to assign any limits to human progress in a fardistant future , Ave must sorrowfully admit that the lot of the Avorking man , as far as Ave see at present , cannot but be one of comparative hardship . It is as a Avorkman that he must be improved—not as something else . One Avould have thought that the educated class , Avhose position and habits of thought are most favourable to broad and general viewswould have been the first to recognise this

, truth ; while the thoughtful Avorking man , Avhoismostdissatisfied Avith his lot , might have been expected to be most individual in his vieivs , most bent on extricating himself from the struggling mass , careless what might become of his fellows . The reverse is the fact . The upper classes—fche so-called philanthropists most actively of all—¦ preach this selfish doctrine to him ; hut he stops his ears . Get on in the Avorld—this is their first and great commandment . It is as though Davy , instead of inventing the safety lamp , had persuaded

a miner here aud there fco take to some occupation in the upper air . Who are the heroes of Dr . Smiles and the British Workman ? 'Self-made men / as the cant phrase is , men AA-IIO hive raised themselves from fche position of labourers to that of capitalists . Such are the modeis proposed to the proletary for his imitation ! Such is the out-look offered him from his painful drudgery ! Now , the best Avorking men see the combined folly and meanness of such counsel as this . The reply—It is a mockery to tell us of this or

that individual Ai-ho has risen from indigence to Avealth . The Government which amuses its miserable subjects AA-lth lotteries , is thought to have reached the loivest depth of baseness . This is a lottery which you offer us , and one Avith remarkably few prizes . All of us have known , hundreds of steady , industrious men , Avho have tried in vain to better themselves in life . Besides , you , the respectable classes , frequently find the pushing , money-making men , deficient , if not in honesty , yet in those finer qualities Avhich command

respect aucl affection . So do Ave . Why should you set such a type before us as a model , when you sneer at it in your oivn rank of life ? But further than this , if you overlook the interests of society , Ave do not . AVe , the vast majority of the community , are overworked and underpaid , and are otherivise in a very unsatisfactory state . HOAV are we the better—IIOAV is society the better , because one of our number has become a capitalist ? You have still before you the miserable , discontented mass , as great a difficulty and scandal as before . "

Correspondence.

CORRESPONDENCE .

T / ifi Editor is not responsible for the opinions expressed & # Correspondents . "BRO . G . M . TWEDDELL AND EREEMASONRY IN AMERICA . " TO THE EDITOn OU THE FREEMASONS MAGAZINE AND MASONIC MIIU 10 H . " WhHal'tis my AvocationHal ; 'tis no sin for a man to labour

y , , , in his vocation . " - —Henry IV ., Part I ., Act I ., scene 2 nd . DEAR Silt AND BROTHEII ,- —The words of Falstaff came to my mind when I read the letter of H . N ., under the above head , at page 329 of your Magazine ; and I also thought of Falstaff ' s men in buff , when I found your correspondent charging me Avith having "twice attacked him"for his assertion that " Masonry in America is , at this time , virtually

defunct . " I shall briefly reply to your correspondent , after Avhich I shall cease to appear in your " Correspondence " until I can express a difference of opinion Avith Masons with the same toleration as I have been accustomed to receive amongst the outer world , who are not Masons . First , then , dear Sir and Brother , I did not attack H . M . twice , and I fancy the imagination that can transform my

communication at page 311 into an attack , must be a fertile one . Secondly , the " attack , " if such it must be considered , which I did make at page 175 , was not on H . M ., but on " the startling statement" Avhich he had been weak enough to make , of which I then saic \ : " This strange assertion appears to me so utterly opposed to the great Masonic virtue , truth , that I charitably hope the Avriterif ha be a Freemasonhas not

, , expressed what he meant to have clone . " Now , however , that he has returned to the attack , and imputed base motives to the whole American brotherhood , and to myself for simply defending , as in duty hound , the characters of my absenfc brother Master Masons , the same as though they were present , the only course left me is to withdraw the charitable hope which I had expressed concerning him .

I Avill pass by the assertions your correspondent has given expression to , that am making Masonic capital out of it , as utterly unworthy of reply . I remember , one Saturday afternoon , accompanying my friend Thomas Wright , the prison , philanthropist , through the cells of the NBAV Bailey at Salford . On returning at night by the train , to the Industrial School in which I was then engaged , I was

speaking to an acquaintance of the assiduity with which my friend had devoted himself through life to his benevolent labours , Avhen another person in tho carriage , who had been listening to the conversation , very innocently asked— "But how does he make it pay ? " He had no idea of martyrs dying afc the stake for conscience sake ; of patriots enduring years of exile or of slavery for their country ' s redemption ;

of John HoAvards , and Mrs . Frys , and Thomas "Wri ghts , devoting their lives to visiting and endeavouring to benefit the fallen brothers and sisters of the human race AA'hen in prison ; and it needed but feAv questions to draAV from him sufficient evidence to prove that his highest conception of good Avas " getting on in the Avorld . " Bufc from us Masons , Avhobefore Ave Avere alloAved to take upon ourselves our

, solemn obligations , ivere obliged solemnly to declare that we " are prompted to solicit those privileges from a favourable opinion preconceived of the institution , a general desire of knowledge , and a sincere wish to render ourselves more extensively serviceable to our felloAV-creatures !"—from us , who are taught to overlook all differences of creed , country , and party , in one common brotherhood ; for us , last of all men ,

ought uncharitable surmisings and unkind speeches and letters to spring . I am sorry , therefore , that your correspondent ' s letter should breathe throughout the spirit which it does ; and I would not have condescended to answer it ,

had ho not charged me Avith having done him an injustice in not making sufficient allowance for the word " virtually . " Now , clear sir and brother , I cannot see hoAv this mends his position . Better , by far , that Freemasonry was totally defunct , if such a thing were possible , than that it should be virtually so . H . N . kindly treats me to Dr . Johnson ' s definition of the word . I am obliged to him for doing so ;

I have great respect for Dr . Johnson for the noble manner in which he produced that dictionary-Avithout the Chesterfields of the day . But if it be nofc heresy ( and ifc really does seem very dangerous to hazard an opinion in your pages ) , I think Walker ' s definition is a better , because a plainer , one than good old Johnson ' s ; and " Walker defines virtually to mean "In effect , though not formally . " If , then ,

Freemasonry in America be " virtually defunct , " it is the same with our American brethren as Avith those false servants of G-od mentioned by St . Paul , in the Second Epistle to Timothy , Avho , instead of being " vessels unto honour , sanctified and meet to the Master ' s use and prepared unto every good work , " are " lovers of their own selves , covetous , boasters , proud , blasphemers , disobedient to parents ,

unthankful , unholy , Avithout natural affections , truce-breakers , false accusers , incontinent , fierce , despisers of those that are good , traitors , heady , high-minded , lovers of pleasure more than lovers of God , having a form of godliness , but denying the power thereof . " If our American brethren are such-like persons as these , then is our holy Craft " virtually defunct " amongst them , hoAvever they may play Avith its gloi'ious

symbols and bedeck themselves Avith its trappings . But if , as the letter from our NOAV York brother eloquently affirms , " at no previous time has Masonry been in so flourishing a condition in America as at present , nor were ever the sublime principles which it inculcates more sincerely practised than

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1861-11-09, Page 11” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 31 March 2023, www.masonicperiodicals.org/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_09111861/page/11/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
HONORARY PAST GRAND OFFICERS. Article 1
THE CONSTITUTIONS OF FREEMASONRY. Article 2
CLASSICAL THEOLOGY—LI. Article 3
ARCHITECHRE AND ARCHÆOLOGY. Article 4
THE NEW POST-OFFICE BUILDINGS AND INDUSTRIAL MUSEUM AT EDINBURGH. Article 5
GENERAL ARCHITECTURAL INTELLIGENCE. Article 6
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 7
NOTES ON LITERATURE SCIENCE AND ART. Article 9
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 11
PROPOSED MASONIC HALL AT BRIGHTON. Article 12
THE MASONIC MIRROR. Article 13
METROPOLITAN. Article 13
PROVINCIAL. Article 13
NORFOLK. Article 14
COLONIAL. Article 15
TURKEY. Article 15
ROYAL ARCH. Article 15
MARK MASONRY. Article 16
Obituary. Article 17
NOTES ON MUSIC AND THE DRAMA. Article 17
PUBLIC AMUSEMENTS. Article 18
THE WEEK Article 18
SPECIAL NOTICE. Article 20
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

2 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

2 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

3 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

2 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

3 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

2 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

1 Article
Page 11

Page 11

2 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

3 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

4 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

1 Article
Page 15

Page 15

5 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

3 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

3 Articles
Page 18

Page 18

3 Articles
Page 19

Page 19

1 Article
Page 20

Page 20

4 Articles
Page 11

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Notes On Literature Science And Art.

tenth century the wages for lifting this stone Avas only one penny per man per diem . The Pinnacle and Eildon quarries now supply the neighbourhood . " The death of Mrs . Pye , relict of the late Henry Pye , reminds the world of a former poet-laureate , who ivas so little of a poet that his very name is almost forgotten . The Westminster Revieio thus hits the selfishness Avhich is

currently taught in the present day : — " If there is one thing more certain than another , it is , that the large majority of mankind must always live by the labour of their hands . In the eyes , therefore , of the political philosopher , AA-hatever concerns labour is of paramoufc importance . To give the labouring class such habits and such opportunities as may tend to raise it as a Avhole , is the object he has most at heart . Increased production , extended commerce , political liberty , the progress of science , he

regards ivifch indifference if they have not this tendency . For Avithout pretending to assign any limits to human progress in a fardistant future , Ave must sorrowfully admit that the lot of the Avorking man , as far as Ave see at present , cannot but be one of comparative hardship . It is as a Avorkman that he must be improved—not as something else . One Avould have thought that the educated class , Avhose position and habits of thought are most favourable to broad and general viewswould have been the first to recognise this

, truth ; while the thoughtful Avorking man , Avhoismostdissatisfied Avith his lot , might have been expected to be most individual in his vieivs , most bent on extricating himself from the struggling mass , careless what might become of his fellows . The reverse is the fact . The upper classes—fche so-called philanthropists most actively of all—¦ preach this selfish doctrine to him ; hut he stops his ears . Get on in the Avorld—this is their first and great commandment . It is as though Davy , instead of inventing the safety lamp , had persuaded

a miner here aud there fco take to some occupation in the upper air . Who are the heroes of Dr . Smiles and the British Workman ? 'Self-made men / as the cant phrase is , men AA-IIO hive raised themselves from fche position of labourers to that of capitalists . Such are the modeis proposed to the proletary for his imitation ! Such is the out-look offered him from his painful drudgery ! Now , the best Avorking men see the combined folly and meanness of such counsel as this . The reply—It is a mockery to tell us of this or

that individual Ai-ho has risen from indigence to Avealth . The Government which amuses its miserable subjects AA-lth lotteries , is thought to have reached the loivest depth of baseness . This is a lottery which you offer us , and one Avith remarkably few prizes . All of us have known , hundreds of steady , industrious men , Avho have tried in vain to better themselves in life . Besides , you , the respectable classes , frequently find the pushing , money-making men , deficient , if not in honesty , yet in those finer qualities Avhich command

respect aucl affection . So do Ave . Why should you set such a type before us as a model , when you sneer at it in your oivn rank of life ? But further than this , if you overlook the interests of society , Ave do not . AVe , the vast majority of the community , are overworked and underpaid , and are otherivise in a very unsatisfactory state . HOAV are we the better—IIOAV is society the better , because one of our number has become a capitalist ? You have still before you the miserable , discontented mass , as great a difficulty and scandal as before . "

Correspondence.

CORRESPONDENCE .

T / ifi Editor is not responsible for the opinions expressed & # Correspondents . "BRO . G . M . TWEDDELL AND EREEMASONRY IN AMERICA . " TO THE EDITOn OU THE FREEMASONS MAGAZINE AND MASONIC MIIU 10 H . " WhHal'tis my AvocationHal ; 'tis no sin for a man to labour

y , , , in his vocation . " - —Henry IV ., Part I ., Act I ., scene 2 nd . DEAR Silt AND BROTHEII ,- —The words of Falstaff came to my mind when I read the letter of H . N ., under the above head , at page 329 of your Magazine ; and I also thought of Falstaff ' s men in buff , when I found your correspondent charging me Avith having "twice attacked him"for his assertion that " Masonry in America is , at this time , virtually

defunct . " I shall briefly reply to your correspondent , after Avhich I shall cease to appear in your " Correspondence " until I can express a difference of opinion Avith Masons with the same toleration as I have been accustomed to receive amongst the outer world , who are not Masons . First , then , dear Sir and Brother , I did not attack H . M . twice , and I fancy the imagination that can transform my

communication at page 311 into an attack , must be a fertile one . Secondly , the " attack , " if such it must be considered , which I did make at page 175 , was not on H . M ., but on " the startling statement" Avhich he had been weak enough to make , of which I then saic \ : " This strange assertion appears to me so utterly opposed to the great Masonic virtue , truth , that I charitably hope the Avriterif ha be a Freemasonhas not

, , expressed what he meant to have clone . " Now , however , that he has returned to the attack , and imputed base motives to the whole American brotherhood , and to myself for simply defending , as in duty hound , the characters of my absenfc brother Master Masons , the same as though they were present , the only course left me is to withdraw the charitable hope which I had expressed concerning him .

I Avill pass by the assertions your correspondent has given expression to , that am making Masonic capital out of it , as utterly unworthy of reply . I remember , one Saturday afternoon , accompanying my friend Thomas Wright , the prison , philanthropist , through the cells of the NBAV Bailey at Salford . On returning at night by the train , to the Industrial School in which I was then engaged , I was

speaking to an acquaintance of the assiduity with which my friend had devoted himself through life to his benevolent labours , Avhen another person in tho carriage , who had been listening to the conversation , very innocently asked— "But how does he make it pay ? " He had no idea of martyrs dying afc the stake for conscience sake ; of patriots enduring years of exile or of slavery for their country ' s redemption ;

of John HoAvards , and Mrs . Frys , and Thomas "Wri ghts , devoting their lives to visiting and endeavouring to benefit the fallen brothers and sisters of the human race AA'hen in prison ; and it needed but feAv questions to draAV from him sufficient evidence to prove that his highest conception of good Avas " getting on in the Avorld . " Bufc from us Masons , Avhobefore Ave Avere alloAved to take upon ourselves our

, solemn obligations , ivere obliged solemnly to declare that we " are prompted to solicit those privileges from a favourable opinion preconceived of the institution , a general desire of knowledge , and a sincere wish to render ourselves more extensively serviceable to our felloAV-creatures !"—from us , who are taught to overlook all differences of creed , country , and party , in one common brotherhood ; for us , last of all men ,

ought uncharitable surmisings and unkind speeches and letters to spring . I am sorry , therefore , that your correspondent ' s letter should breathe throughout the spirit which it does ; and I would not have condescended to answer it ,

had ho not charged me Avith having done him an injustice in not making sufficient allowance for the word " virtually . " Now , clear sir and brother , I cannot see hoAv this mends his position . Better , by far , that Freemasonry was totally defunct , if such a thing were possible , than that it should be virtually so . H . N . kindly treats me to Dr . Johnson ' s definition of the word . I am obliged to him for doing so ;

I have great respect for Dr . Johnson for the noble manner in which he produced that dictionary-Avithout the Chesterfields of the day . But if it be nofc heresy ( and ifc really does seem very dangerous to hazard an opinion in your pages ) , I think Walker ' s definition is a better , because a plainer , one than good old Johnson ' s ; and " Walker defines virtually to mean "In effect , though not formally . " If , then ,

Freemasonry in America be " virtually defunct , " it is the same with our American brethren as Avith those false servants of G-od mentioned by St . Paul , in the Second Epistle to Timothy , Avho , instead of being " vessels unto honour , sanctified and meet to the Master ' s use and prepared unto every good work , " are " lovers of their own selves , covetous , boasters , proud , blasphemers , disobedient to parents ,

unthankful , unholy , Avithout natural affections , truce-breakers , false accusers , incontinent , fierce , despisers of those that are good , traitors , heady , high-minded , lovers of pleasure more than lovers of God , having a form of godliness , but denying the power thereof . " If our American brethren are such-like persons as these , then is our holy Craft " virtually defunct " amongst them , hoAvever they may play Avith its gloi'ious

symbols and bedeck themselves Avith its trappings . But if , as the letter from our NOAV York brother eloquently affirms , " at no previous time has Masonry been in so flourishing a condition in America as at present , nor were ever the sublime principles which it inculcates more sincerely practised than

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 10
  • You're on page11
  • 12
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2023

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy