Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • Nov. 9, 1861
  • Page 5
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Nov. 9, 1861: Page 5

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Nov. 9, 1861
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article ARCHITECHRE AND ARCHÆOLOGY. ← Page 2 of 2
    Article ARCHITECHRE AND ARCHÆOLOGY. Page 2 of 2
    Article THE NEW POST-OFFICE BUILDINGS AND INDUSTRIAL MUSEUM AT EDINBURGH. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 5

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Architechre And Archæology.

scrupulously attend to ; bufc have no self-doctoring' on his part , no interference in your especial province ; here the artist should reign supreme . Ifc may well be doubted whether architects , as a class , do not tell their clients , the public , to much about the names and outward characteristics of various styles in an easy , smattering-mannerwhich leads them to believe thafc they not only

, may , but are invited to choose for themselves , as the caprice or fancy of the moment may dictate . Ifc is ten fco one that Avhen Ave hear an old gentleman in public or private discussing the relative merits of Classic and Gothic ( a subject of which he is most likely profoundly ignorant , and for which he really cares not a sfcraAv ) , ho is making use of haskneyed terms and threadbare descriptions AvhicliAve architects have put into his hands ,

and Avhich ho flings about as intelligently and usefully as a boy throwing stones in the street . No doubt , one of the most formidable difficulties a young architect can haA'e to encounter in commencing his career is to mako people ( particularly friends AA'ho only think aboufc his " getting on ") understand clearly that he has such a thing as a principle , Avhich prevents him from attempting to practise a variety of styles ;

and the sooner he faces this difficulty boldly and grapples with it , the better for the public auct the better for him . Let him , by all moans , study good art of every description , but the style which he AVOOS and Avins , —Avhich he can SAvear to love , honour , and obey , —must be one and one only . If ifc were possible for us , as a body , to agree on this point ,

our progress Avould , indeed , be certain and immediate , but I knoAV very well that the vision is Utopian ; such a thing is , at present , at least , au impossibility . Perhaps one of the greatest obstacles to anything like unanimity on this subject is tho intolerable rage for so-called originality in our day . . Each young architect seems to think himself bound to outdo every one else in brofceu-baoked AVUKIOAVS , or in some

diseased form of chamber ; but the worst stage ofthe malady is Avhon Ave hear a complete neiv style talked of . The very mention of the Victorian style is enough to mako one ' s heart sink within one , and tremble for the prospects of art . Such a thing as tho creation of a IIOAV style would be so complete a falsification of all history and all analogy , that Ave may at once safely disabuse our mind of any such expectation . In

architecture , at least , if in nothing else , the development theoi * y is tha true one , and thafc development must be gradual , and , to acertain extent , almost unconscious . As in the human -frame , the varionsvital processes are carried on unconsciously to himself in the healthy man , and any continued introversion of thought directed to a particular organ mosfc surely causes derangement and disease , —so Ave may Avell fear lest

amy attempt to force tho natural development of our art by a morbid straining after originality may havo the most disastrous results . This very fault was ono of the chief causes of the decline of Medkeval art . Let us guard against it IIOAV , and remember that the man who , from selfish motives of vanity and caprice , attempts to force himself to the front by extravagant sallies and inflated attempts at originality , is no true benefactor to art , but rather thc reverse .

On this point I cannot resist quoting - an admirable passage from an address delivered nearly a hundred years ago by thc first President of tho E , oyal Academy : — " It is evident , " says Sir Joshtia Reynolds , "that a great part of every man ' s life must be employed in collecting materials for the exercise of genius . Invention , strictly speaking , is little rnorc than a UOAV combination of those images which have

been previously gathered and deposited iu the memory ; nothing can come of nothing ; he who has laid np no materials can produce no combinations . A student unacquainted Avith the attempts of former adventurers is always apt to overrate his OAVU abilities , to mistake the most trifling excursions for discoveries of moment , and every coast IIOAV to him for a IIOAV found country , if , by chance , he passes

beyond his usual limits , he congratulates his OAVII arrival at those regions Avhich they AA'ho have steered a better course have left behind them ; and the productions of such minds are seldom distinguished by an air of originality . They are anticipated in their happiest efforts , aud if they are found to differ in anything from their predecessors , it is only in irregular sallies and trifling conceits . The more extensive , therefore , your acquaintance is Avith the works of those who

Architechre And Archæology.

havo excelled , tho more extensive will be your powers of invention , aud , whafc may appear still more like a paradox , tho more original ii'ill be your conceptions . Bufc the difficult } ' on this occasion is to determine what ought to bo proposed as models of excellence , aud Avho ought to be considered as fche properest guides . " Thc difficulty AA'hich Sir Joshua found on that occasion

Avill probably be felfc fco lie much the same on this , but the discussion of styles is ono of Avhich AVO are all rather tired ; and as my own A'iews are , I believe , pretty AVCII known , I shall not attempt to apologise for Avhat may seem fche exclusiveness of my advice on this point . I address myself to the young student Avho has chosen what i believe to be the true foundation for his efforts , and

AA'ho subscribes to Sir Joshua ' s dictum , that the greater part of his life must be spent hi collecting materials , and thafc the more extensive his acquaintance Avith Avorks of excellence , tho more likely is ho to be original in his OAATI conceptions . To him I say , begin afc once ; let your sketch-book be constantly in 3 'our hand : never lose au opportunity of examining , measuring , and sketching Mediarval buildings for

yourself , and learning their uses and thc principles AA'hich guided their architects : and in sketching them take care to sketch intelligently , nofc always with a A-ieev fco picking up little bits here and there to make use of afterwards ( that is not the Avay to collect materials ) , but with a leading purpose of understanding some principle , or of illustrating some phaso or developement hitherto new to you .

I recollect once seeing a young architect spend about two hours in tracing the profile of a cluster of vaulting ribs on an Early English cap . When he had finished Avith great labour , thc dravriing Avas quite correct , I believe , and very neat , but it was perfectly useless and unirrfcelligible . If he had made a little plan of a bay of the A'anlting , Avith a perspective sketch , and added a section or plan above the point

where the ribs parted , his sketch would have been complete and useful , and he Avould have carried down his ribs and gofc the profile on his cap in a few minutes . I mention this anecdote merely to illustrate what I mean by intelligent as distinguished from untintelligcnt sketching , and it is much to be wished that many amongst us AVIIO haA'e plenty of ability , could bo led to feel tho fascination as well as the use of this manner of collecting materials . ( To he continued . )

The New Post-Office Buildings And Industrial Museum At Edinburgh.

THE NEW POST-OFFICE BUILDINGS AND INDUSTRIAL MUSEUM AT EDINBURGH .

H . R . H . tho Prince Consort has just laid the foundationstone of tho neiv post-office , on the site formerly occupied hy tho Theatre Royal , and Shakcspeare-squaro . Tho edifice will be more or less seen on all sides , tho north , Avest , and south elevations being particularly conspicuous . Of these three , hoAvever , tlie north and Avest may be considered tho

most important—the one facing tho Register House , and the other , or side elevation , extending along . North Bridge-street , opposite Avhat is called tho New Buildings . Thc south end , which will be seen vei-y prominently from the North-bridge , is also an important and difficult feature , and thc ai-chiteefc seems to have handled ifc' very successfully . The frontage

towards Princes ' -streefc ivill extend to about i 50 fc , and that to ' . varcls the bridge about 180 ft . The style of architecture adopted is the Italian . The UAVO chief facades present a broken outline , the central portion being of tAVO stories , while the ends rise with something of tower-like effect into throe stories . The cornice of the building will bo on a level wifch the top of the domes on tho corner towers of the

Register House . The southern and eastern elevations , necessarily from the nature of the ground , each exhibit six stories . " The main entrance , that to the public , lobby , is from Princes ' -streefc , aud consists of throe large open archways . The pi'inciple of design throughout on the basement floor is a succession of deeply-recessed arched windows , Avifch .

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1861-11-09, Page 5” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 31 March 2023, www.masonicperiodicals.org/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_09111861/page/5/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
HONORARY PAST GRAND OFFICERS. Article 1
THE CONSTITUTIONS OF FREEMASONRY. Article 2
CLASSICAL THEOLOGY—LI. Article 3
ARCHITECHRE AND ARCHÆOLOGY. Article 4
THE NEW POST-OFFICE BUILDINGS AND INDUSTRIAL MUSEUM AT EDINBURGH. Article 5
GENERAL ARCHITECTURAL INTELLIGENCE. Article 6
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 7
NOTES ON LITERATURE SCIENCE AND ART. Article 9
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 11
PROPOSED MASONIC HALL AT BRIGHTON. Article 12
THE MASONIC MIRROR. Article 13
METROPOLITAN. Article 13
PROVINCIAL. Article 13
NORFOLK. Article 14
COLONIAL. Article 15
TURKEY. Article 15
ROYAL ARCH. Article 15
MARK MASONRY. Article 16
Obituary. Article 17
NOTES ON MUSIC AND THE DRAMA. Article 17
PUBLIC AMUSEMENTS. Article 18
THE WEEK Article 18
SPECIAL NOTICE. Article 20
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

2 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

2 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

3 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

2 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

3 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

2 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

1 Article
Page 11

Page 11

2 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

3 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

4 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

1 Article
Page 15

Page 15

5 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

3 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

3 Articles
Page 18

Page 18

3 Articles
Page 19

Page 19

1 Article
Page 20

Page 20

4 Articles
Page 5

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Architechre And Archæology.

scrupulously attend to ; bufc have no self-doctoring' on his part , no interference in your especial province ; here the artist should reign supreme . Ifc may well be doubted whether architects , as a class , do not tell their clients , the public , to much about the names and outward characteristics of various styles in an easy , smattering-mannerwhich leads them to believe thafc they not only

, may , but are invited to choose for themselves , as the caprice or fancy of the moment may dictate . Ifc is ten fco one that Avhen Ave hear an old gentleman in public or private discussing the relative merits of Classic and Gothic ( a subject of which he is most likely profoundly ignorant , and for which he really cares not a sfcraAv ) , ho is making use of haskneyed terms and threadbare descriptions AvhicliAve architects have put into his hands ,

and Avhich ho flings about as intelligently and usefully as a boy throwing stones in the street . No doubt , one of the most formidable difficulties a young architect can haA'e to encounter in commencing his career is to mako people ( particularly friends AA'ho only think aboufc his " getting on ") understand clearly that he has such a thing as a principle , Avhich prevents him from attempting to practise a variety of styles ;

and the sooner he faces this difficulty boldly and grapples with it , the better for the public auct the better for him . Let him , by all moans , study good art of every description , but the style which he AVOOS and Avins , —Avhich he can SAvear to love , honour , and obey , —must be one and one only . If ifc were possible for us , as a body , to agree on this point ,

our progress Avould , indeed , be certain and immediate , but I knoAV very well that the vision is Utopian ; such a thing is , at present , at least , au impossibility . Perhaps one of the greatest obstacles to anything like unanimity on this subject is tho intolerable rage for so-called originality in our day . . Each young architect seems to think himself bound to outdo every one else in brofceu-baoked AVUKIOAVS , or in some

diseased form of chamber ; but the worst stage ofthe malady is Avhon Ave hear a complete neiv style talked of . The very mention of the Victorian style is enough to mako one ' s heart sink within one , and tremble for the prospects of art . Such a thing as tho creation of a IIOAV style would be so complete a falsification of all history and all analogy , that Ave may at once safely disabuse our mind of any such expectation . In

architecture , at least , if in nothing else , the development theoi * y is tha true one , and thafc development must be gradual , and , to acertain extent , almost unconscious . As in the human -frame , the varionsvital processes are carried on unconsciously to himself in the healthy man , and any continued introversion of thought directed to a particular organ mosfc surely causes derangement and disease , —so Ave may Avell fear lest

amy attempt to force tho natural development of our art by a morbid straining after originality may havo the most disastrous results . This very fault was ono of the chief causes of the decline of Medkeval art . Let us guard against it IIOAV , and remember that the man who , from selfish motives of vanity and caprice , attempts to force himself to the front by extravagant sallies and inflated attempts at originality , is no true benefactor to art , but rather thc reverse .

On this point I cannot resist quoting - an admirable passage from an address delivered nearly a hundred years ago by thc first President of tho E , oyal Academy : — " It is evident , " says Sir Joshtia Reynolds , "that a great part of every man ' s life must be employed in collecting materials for the exercise of genius . Invention , strictly speaking , is little rnorc than a UOAV combination of those images which have

been previously gathered and deposited iu the memory ; nothing can come of nothing ; he who has laid np no materials can produce no combinations . A student unacquainted Avith the attempts of former adventurers is always apt to overrate his OAVU abilities , to mistake the most trifling excursions for discoveries of moment , and every coast IIOAV to him for a IIOAV found country , if , by chance , he passes

beyond his usual limits , he congratulates his OAVII arrival at those regions Avhich they AA'ho have steered a better course have left behind them ; and the productions of such minds are seldom distinguished by an air of originality . They are anticipated in their happiest efforts , aud if they are found to differ in anything from their predecessors , it is only in irregular sallies and trifling conceits . The more extensive , therefore , your acquaintance is Avith the works of those who

Architechre And Archæology.

havo excelled , tho more extensive will be your powers of invention , aud , whafc may appear still more like a paradox , tho more original ii'ill be your conceptions . Bufc the difficult } ' on this occasion is to determine what ought to bo proposed as models of excellence , aud Avho ought to be considered as fche properest guides . " Thc difficulty AA'hich Sir Joshua found on that occasion

Avill probably be felfc fco lie much the same on this , but the discussion of styles is ono of Avhich AVO are all rather tired ; and as my own A'iews are , I believe , pretty AVCII known , I shall not attempt to apologise for Avhat may seem fche exclusiveness of my advice on this point . I address myself to the young student Avho has chosen what i believe to be the true foundation for his efforts , and

AA'ho subscribes to Sir Joshua ' s dictum , that the greater part of his life must be spent hi collecting materials , and thafc the more extensive his acquaintance Avith Avorks of excellence , tho more likely is ho to be original in his OAATI conceptions . To him I say , begin afc once ; let your sketch-book be constantly in 3 'our hand : never lose au opportunity of examining , measuring , and sketching Mediarval buildings for

yourself , and learning their uses and thc principles AA'hich guided their architects : and in sketching them take care to sketch intelligently , nofc always with a A-ieev fco picking up little bits here and there to make use of afterwards ( that is not the Avay to collect materials ) , but with a leading purpose of understanding some principle , or of illustrating some phaso or developement hitherto new to you .

I recollect once seeing a young architect spend about two hours in tracing the profile of a cluster of vaulting ribs on an Early English cap . When he had finished Avith great labour , thc dravriing Avas quite correct , I believe , and very neat , but it was perfectly useless and unirrfcelligible . If he had made a little plan of a bay of the A'anlting , Avith a perspective sketch , and added a section or plan above the point

where the ribs parted , his sketch would have been complete and useful , and he Avould have carried down his ribs and gofc the profile on his cap in a few minutes . I mention this anecdote merely to illustrate what I mean by intelligent as distinguished from untintelligcnt sketching , and it is much to be wished that many amongst us AVIIO haA'e plenty of ability , could bo led to feel tho fascination as well as the use of this manner of collecting materials . ( To he continued . )

The New Post-Office Buildings And Industrial Museum At Edinburgh.

THE NEW POST-OFFICE BUILDINGS AND INDUSTRIAL MUSEUM AT EDINBURGH .

H . R . H . tho Prince Consort has just laid the foundationstone of tho neiv post-office , on the site formerly occupied hy tho Theatre Royal , and Shakcspeare-squaro . Tho edifice will be more or less seen on all sides , tho north , Avest , and south elevations being particularly conspicuous . Of these three , hoAvever , tlie north and Avest may be considered tho

most important—the one facing tho Register House , and the other , or side elevation , extending along . North Bridge-street , opposite Avhat is called tho New Buildings . Thc south end , which will be seen vei-y prominently from the North-bridge , is also an important and difficult feature , and thc ai-chiteefc seems to have handled ifc' very successfully . The frontage

towards Princes ' -streefc ivill extend to about i 50 fc , and that to ' . varcls the bridge about 180 ft . The style of architecture adopted is the Italian . The UAVO chief facades present a broken outline , the central portion being of tAVO stories , while the ends rise with something of tower-like effect into throe stories . The cornice of the building will bo on a level wifch the top of the domes on tho corner towers of the

Register House . The southern and eastern elevations , necessarily from the nature of the ground , each exhibit six stories . " The main entrance , that to the public , lobby , is from Princes ' -streefc , aud consists of throe large open archways . The pi'inciple of design throughout on the basement floor is a succession of deeply-recessed arched windows , Avifch .

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 4
  • You're on page5
  • 6
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2023

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy